caltide.ai

Intermittent Fasting Schedule: How to Pick Between 16:8, 18:6 and 20:4

The best intermittent fasting schedule for most people is 16:8, with an eight hour eating window placed around your work and training hours. Longer fasts like 18:6 or 20:4 only help if they make it easier for you to stay in a calorie deficit. They do not burn extra fat on their own.

Jay HoldenPublished · Updated · 7 min read
Clock face split into a long fasting period and a shorter eating window, with black coffee and a balanced meal below
Key takeaways The short version, before the details.
  1. Start with 16:8 and set the eating window around your day, not the other way round.
  2. Use 18:6, 20:4 or a 24 hour fast only if eating fewer meals makes your calorie target easier to hit.
  3. Trials that compare fasting with plain calorie cutting find similar weight loss when calories match.
  4. Skip fasting if you are pregnant, breastfeeding, under 18, have had an eating disorder or take medicines that can cause low blood sugar.

Intermittent fasting schedule compared: 16:8, 18:6, 20:4 and 24 hours

In each schedule the first number is the hours you fast and the second is the hours you eat. The clock time is up to you. A good window covers the meals you care about most, such as a family dinner, a work lunch or the meal after training, so you are not fighting your own calendar.

The table shows sample windows for three common days: an early riser who is up at 5:30am, a late worker whose shift ends around 11pm, and someone who trains at 6pm.

ScheduleEarly riserLate workerEvening trainerMeals that fit
16:87am to 3pm2pm to 10pm12pm to 8pm2 or 3 meals
18:68am to 2pm3pm to 9pm2pm to 8pm2 meals and a snack
20:410am to 2pm5pm to 9pm4pm to 8pm1 large meal or 2 small ones
24 hoursDinner to dinner, 1 or 2 days a weekLate meal to late meal on a day offRest day only, never before a hard sessionNormal eating the other days

How to pick your eating window

  • Anchor it to the meal you won't skip. If dinner with family at 7pm matters, end the window at 8pm, not 3pm.
  • Eat after training. Evening trainers do better with the window open past their session, so the post-workout meal falls inside it.
  • Keep it the same on most days. A window that moves every day is hard to remember and easy to give up on.
  • Leave a few hours before bed. Ending the window two or three hours before sleep suits most people.

How does 16-8 intermittent fasting work in a normal day?

With 16-8 intermittent fasting you eat within an eight hour window and fast for the other sixteen, most of them while you sleep. Finish dinner at 8pm, sleep, and your first meal is at noon the next day. In practice you skip breakfast and late snacks.

Water, black coffee and plain tea are fine during the fast. Anything with calories, such as milk, sugar, juice or a protein shake, counts as eating. Many people find the first week the hardest, then the morning hunger settles as the body gets used to the new meal times.

Inside the window you still eat normal, balanced meals. Fasting does not make up for a window full of takeaway, and it does not stop you eating your usual daily calories in eight hours.

Does intermittent fasting work for weight loss?

Yes, but for the same reason any diet works: you eat less energy than you burn. Fasting is a way to limit when you eat, which often means fewer snacks and one less meal. It does not change the energy sum.

The best trials show this. In a 12 month study in the New England Journal of Medicine, people who cut calories and ate between 8am and 4pm lost about as much weight as people who cut the same calories with no time limit. The difference between the groups was not statistically significant. A 2020 trial of 16:8 eating in JAMA Internal Medicine, with no calorie target, found only a small weight loss that was not different from eating three meals a day.

Intermittent fasting for weight loss: same deficit, different timing

Here is one day for someone whose maintenance is 2,300 kcal, eating the same food two ways:

One day at 1,800 kcal, two ways

Maintenance calories2,300 kcal
16:8, two meals and a snack from 12pm to 8pm1,800 kcal
Three meals from 7am to 8pm1,800 kcal
Deficit in both cases500 kcal

Eat 2,500 kcal inside the same 8 hour window and the day ends 200 kcal over maintenance, fasting or not.

So the useful question is not which schedule burns more fat, but which one makes 1,800 kcal feel easy for you. If skipping breakfast keeps you from grazing, fasting helps. If it makes you so hungry that dinner runs to 1,500 kcal, it does not. Find your own maintenance number first with the TDEE calculator.

Know your daily target firstSee how many calories to eat to lose weight, from your size and activity.Open calculator

When are 18:6, 20:4 and 24 hour fasts worth it?

A longer fast is worth trying when 16:8 already feels easy and you would rather eat two bigger meals than three smaller ones. Some people like that a 20:4 day leaves room for one large, satisfying dinner.

Watch for the signs that it is working against you:

  • You overeat in the window and the week's total does not drop.
  • Training feels flat, or you lose strength over several weeks.
  • You struggle to fit enough protein into two meals.
  • A long fast turns into a weekend of making up for it, which works just like a cheat day and can cancel most of the week's deficit.

A 24 hour fast is best kept to one or two non-consecutive days a week, on a rest day, with normal eating on the other days.

Is intermittent fasting healthy, and who should skip it?

For most healthy adults, a 16:8 schedule with normal, balanced meals is safe. Johns Hopkins Medicine notes that it can help with weight and some blood sugar markers, while also listing groups who should not try it. Expect some hunger, headaches or irritability in the first days.

Skip fasting, or talk to your doctor first, if you:

  • are pregnant or breastfeeding
  • are under 18
  • have had an eating disorder
  • have type 1 diabetes, or take insulin or other medicines that can cause low blood sugar
  • are underweight or recovering from illness
  • take medicines that must be taken with food

The bigger risk for healthy people is eating too little. A short window can squeeze out a meal you needed. If you regularly finish the day well below your energy needs, feel dizzy, sleep badly or lose weight very fast, widen the window or stop.

How to track fasting next to your food log

The Caltide fasting timer runs a fast on the same screen as your food log, so the timing and the calories sit side by side.

  • Pick a length. Choose 16, 18, 20 or 24 hours, or No End for an open fast, and tap Start Fasting.
  • Choose the days. Pick weekdays under Repeat on these days and the fast starts on its own the first time you open Caltide on one of them.
  • See it on Today's log. A Fasting row shows how long you have fasted and when the fast ends. You can move the end with Edit End or stop early with Stop Fast.
  • Logging food does not end it. If you log a food during a fast, the app asks whether to keep fasting or stop, because a cup of tea and a meal look the same to a timer.
  • Review past fasts. Your recent finished fasts appear under Last fasts.

Tide, the coach in the app, still watches the calories. Its warnings are based on your floor, the higher of your BMR and a fixed minimum, not on your fasting window. If several finished days in a week fall below that floor, if today is still below it in the evening, or if your weight trend is falling faster than is safe, Tide tells you. It never lowers your target or hides a log.

The fasting timer is part of a subscription. Food logging and your calorie goal stay free.

Run your fast next to your food log

Set the days and the length once, then see your eating window and your calories on the same screen, with Tide watching for days that end too low.

See plans
Phone showing a fasting timer ring above a day's food log

Frequently asked questions

16:8 is the easiest start because most of the fast happens while you sleep. If that feels hard, begin with 12 or 14 hours, such as 8pm to 8am, and add an hour every few days. Keep the same window on most days and place it around the meals you care about.

Not when calories are equal. Trials that compare the two find similar weight loss. Fasting limits when you eat, and that only helps if it also lowers how much you eat. Many people do best combining both: a set eating window plus a daily calorie target they log against.

Yes. Black coffee, plain tea and water have almost no calories and are fine during the fast. Milk, cream, sugar, syrups and bulletproof coffee add calories, so save them for the eating window. If coffee on an empty stomach upsets you, have it with your first meal instead.

For most healthy women a moderate schedule like 14:10 or 16:8 is fine. Some women notice sleep, mood or cycle changes with long or daily aggressive fasts, so start gently and eat enough inside the window. Women who are pregnant, breastfeeding or have had an eating disorder should not fast.

A 16:8 window can run every day or only on workdays, whichever you will keep up. Many people relax it at weekends. Keep 24 hour fasts to one or two non-consecutive days a week, on rest days. The weekly calorie total matters more than the number of fasting days.